most people with many coins dont like shinies in the first place so itll be hard to find a sell anyways

I disagree with this idea, I trade over 5000-20000 or more coins to get every shinies in the game, I would be completely mad, if they takes out all the shinies pokemon out of every one box, just so you and few peoples can have they a tad rarer. That why we have the other colored pokemon so peoples can have rarer pokemon and newer players that can't afford the colored pokemon at least have a way of get some other form (shinies) beside normal pokemon.

I rate this -10/10

Edit: Bad enough the newer players begs the rich players every times an new promos come out for coins so they can get the promos, we dont need them to begs us also for coins (or for our shinies) so they can get a shinies that cost more now because someone want shinies rarer.

first off i never implied taking away all shinies i just said make them rarer from here on out im implying that scenario while you guys don't really understand the moot point of this. your suggesting a scenario that isn't partaining to my idea

well if they dont remove the shinies just make them rarer then people 20k worth of shinies will have 100k worth of shinies (free 80k)

Shiny pokemon are so expensive though! I mean the promos are always fifty coins or more! Can't we lower it a little bit? D: Alright, in all honesty, I believe shiny pokemon are stable at the moment and will continue to be stable for some time. At the moment, I think keeping them where they are is fine.

1/10

if shinies was rarer then the new players wouldn't have anything to trade for then normal pokemon, and almost NO ONE want normal pokemon (unless it have Toxic or an legendary pokemon or a really high level like in the 4000 range) because they can get it out of the swap or by the map, they mainly want Colored pokemon a.k.a Cursed, Shadow, Rainbow, Golden, Luminous and sometime Shinies pokemon, and the new players wouldn't get any where in the game and quit because no one want to trade with them, partly it the shinies pokemon that help them get coins (neither by trading or by putting the shinies pokemon in the Auction House) to get the colored promos.

also this game is different then handheld game, for couple things (might be more but cant thinks of them),:
1. Any pokemon can learn any moves they normally wouldn't, ex. Charmander can used the moves Bubble, where as the handheld game he can't learns that move,
2. in the Handheld game you have to battle the pokemon to lower down his HP to catch them (unless you have Action Replay thing that can hacked the handheld game, so you can get ton of masterball), on Creed you don't have to, all you do it throw a ball at it (sometime you dont get it though).

so really what the different if this game is little different then the Handheld game.

If they want to makes the shinies pokemon rarer, added some new one that isn't in the game yet (like Zangoose, Tauros, Heracross) to map only (that will makes peoples more active on the maps) and makes them harder to get, but dont get the one that is game now harder (or deleted from the game) to get.

Shinies is like the middle ground between Normal pokemon and all other colored pokemon. Also, it would have to be taken away from people or it will stay just as common