I think it would be cool if, as a bonus for playing the fishing game, you win the one pokemon you entered into the competition. It would be a way to get more pokemon in the game.

I also think there should be a second fishing competition. Maybe where you catch as many pokemon as possible and the points from all of them are added up, and those with the top 3 scores from this game also win prizes. So this game would award time spent over luck.

I like the second idea more than the 1st one.
6/10

This message is hidden because this person has been banned.

If the first one is implemented into the game that means that the rate of legendaries would go down and the second suggestion I kind of like. So for the first suggestion 1/10 and for the second 3/10

i think the two ideas are good and i rate it 9/10
they are creative

The first part would mess up the rates of pokes so 2/10. But the second one is a great idea 8/10. Similar to the bug catching contest in the real Pokemon games.

i like the ideas but for the 2nd idea people would do the fishing game all day so maybe some limitations on how many times you can fish or whatever

Oh yeah, I forgot that some of the legendaries in the fishing game (like Kyogre) are buyable elsewhere.
Still would be nice to have some way to fish up those cool water pokemon in that game that aren't available in Creed yet.

Has been suggested many times ... 4/10 sorry

The first one would cause people just to fish until they got an awesome rare pokemon. I've gotten a Palkia and similar worth 500 so many times... I would just keep it and get the Palkia at the end of the day, haha. And it is every day, so it'd become pretty easy to spam pokemon. Or is that only if you win?

The second one though, that's a 9/10 idea, because in addition to the current hitdown for the lucky, those of us who sit there clicking for 30 minutes to only get one pokemon worth 27,000 can get some reward too. And yes, I do use super rod >_<

0/10 to both, #1 would be too many pokemon entering, #2 would be spammed :/

The second one is actually pretty good. :o
That way it's for effort and time spent fishing which someone might do all day, rather than getting lucky.

im thinking it is not a real good idea.. 4/10

No.. That would make a rate drop. And the fishing is already okay how it is

I agree with the others, by catching the one you entered, the rate would drop... about the second... I kind of like it, since it could give others a chance to win.